Is your boss an algorithm? Paola Tubaro at the ASOR Institute in SantiagoPaola Tubaro was invited to give a talk at the ASOR Institute in Santiago in
early July, and shared some results of her research in order to deepen dialogue
on these important topics.
She discussed how algorithmic management comes with a promise of higher
productivity, but also increases surveillance in companies, while the apparent
autonomy of self-employed workers on platforms—from Rappi delivery drivers to
Workana designers—proves to be illusory.
Her presentation, largely though not exclusively based on this open-access book
chapter, analyzed the consequences of these transformations on job quality at
two key stages of the AI life cycle: its production through human labor
(so-called “data work”) and its deployment in workplaces across various sectors,
from logistics to healthcare.
Taken together, they reveal how AI accelerates preexisting trends in the global
economy: the outsourcing of business functions while maintaining control over
production—a phenomenon studied by D. Weil as the “fissured workplace”—and a
“regime of dispersion,” first theorized by C. Datchary, in which workers manage
multiple disconnected tasks.
To protect job quality, she argued, corporate strategies and labor regulations
must address the cognitive overload associated with fissuring, develop
worker-centered organizational models, and implement safeguards for all users.
The Millennium Institute for Authority and Social Regulation (ASOR), recently
created in Chile, aims to conduct cutting-edge interdisciplinary research on the
decline and reconfiguration of authority relationships in contemporary society
and their impacts on social regulation. Authority, claim the founders of the
Institute, is a pervasive social mechanism that is in place whenever there are
power asymmetries. How people manage authority – in the family, school,
workplace etc. – affects social cohesion and the extent to which (un)healthy
relations of domination may arise.
The rise of algorithmic management, especially AI-supported, is widely thought
to affect labour relationships, endowing our bosses with new tools or even – as
in the exemplary book by Aloisi and De Stefano) that algorithms actually are our
new bosses. At the same time, the rise of platform labour – also closely linked
to the AI boom – has promoted the model of independent workers who have no boss.
Authority in the workplace changes gets more fragmented, disrupting traditional
relational models, not only vertically (the hierarchical chain of command), but
also horizontally (team composition, collegial work). What are the effects?